In episode six of TLC's "Return to Amish," we see Katie Ann settling into her new English life, Jeremiah's secret is out, and Kate make a return to her fashion roots, this time as a designer instead of a model.
Matriarch Mary goes to visit her daughter Katie Ann and said she hasn't spoken to her since she decided to leave the Amish community. Katie Ann is settling in just fine at her brother Abe's house, where she lives with him, his wife Rebecca and their two young children. Rebecca told Katie Ann that just like the Amish have rules for their households, she has one for hers and no Amish clothes are allowed in her home. When Mary visits, she's shocked to see that Katie Ann is already following Rebecca's rule and was wearing an oatmeal colored v-neck shirt and jeans.
"I've come to let you know that I feel bad about the other day," Mary told her daughter, referring to her anger when Katie Ann announced she was leaving her to go live with Abe and Rebecca. Mary apologized to her daughter and let Abe know she isn't mad anymore. Mary reveals a little secret of her own during her on-camera interivew, where she talks about the time she left the Amish community when she was a teenager and ran away with the carnival.
Meanwhile, Kate gets an offer to showcase her new clothing line (as previously reported by HNGN in an exclusive interview) but she only had one month to pull together her outfits. She enlists Mary's help, who's more than happy to assist Kate since Kate has been so helpful to Mary and her bed and breakfast. The two women work fast to help Kate get ready for a photoshoot at the B&B, where Kate's soft and feminine designs look great against the rustic backdrop of the B&B's barn. Jeremiah even lends a hand during the shoot.
But Jeremiah has been hiding a secret and gets caught by Abe and Rebecca while they were in town grocery shopping. They catch Jeremiah dressed in English clothes, holding a cell phone and smoking a cigarette while on his way to buy more English clothes even though he told Mary he wanted to return to the Amish community. Abe is upset because his mother took Jeremiah in, she could get in trouble with the Amish church because Jeremiah is breaking Amish rules under her roof. The episode ends with Abe confronting Jeremiah at the local bar where he works.
"You're lying to me, you're lying to my family and I'm sick and tired of it," Abe tells Jeremiah, and the episode ends with tension.
